The Theological Implications of Original Sin in Islam: Arrogance as the Root of Human Folly

by Dr. Yasemin Saib

In the Islamic tradition, the concept of original sin diverges significantly from the interpretations found in other Abrahamic religions. This essay posits that at the core of what can be paralleled to “original sin” in Islam is not disobedience in the form of eating from a forbidden tree, but rather, arrogance. This arrogance is epitomized in the figure of Shaytan (Satan), whose refusal to prostrate before Adam encapsulates the essence of disobedience to Allah. This essay will explore how arrogance is both the hallmark of Shaytan’s rebellion and a critical challenge to the human spiritual condition, drawing from the Quran, Hadith, and Islamic scholarship to argue that purging arrogance is pivotal in aligning oneself with the path of righteousness.

Shaytan’s Rebellion: The Genesis of Arrogance

The story of Shaytan’s refusal to bow before Adam, as ordered by Allah, is a principal narrative in Islam that underscores the peril of arrogance. Shaytan, once a devout servant of Allah, becomes the epitome of arrogance when he deems himself superior to Adam, justifying his disobedience on the basis of his own creation from fire, in contrast to Adam’s creation from clay. This act of hubris is not merely a personal failing but symbolizes the first instance of outright rebellion against divine command, making arrogance not just a sin but the sin from which all subsequent disobedience stems.

The Consequences of Arrogance

Arrogance, as demonstrated by Shaytan, alienates the individual from the mercy of Allah. It blinds the heart, obscures the truth, and leads one on a path contrary to the one of humility and submission that is central to Islam. The Quran repeatedly warns against arrogance, equating it with self-deception and deviation from the divine path. The consequences of arrogance extend beyond the spiritual realm; they precipitate conflict, engender injustices, and sow discord among people, fracturing the communal harmony that Islam cherishes.

Shaytan’s Objective: A World Led Astray

Shaytan’s objective, post his own fall from grace, is to entice humanity into the same trap of arrogance that led to his downfall. He whispers into the hearts of people, coaxing them to view themselves through a lens of self-aggrandizement and to place their judgment above divine wisdom. The danger is profound; when individuals succumb to arrogance, they not only stray from the path of righteousness but also perpetuate a cycle of disobedience and estrangement from Allah, echoing Shaytan’s original sin. The Path to Redemption: Overcoming Arrogance Overcoming arrogance is thus not merely a personal endeavor but a collective necessity for spiritual health and societal harmony. Islam offers a clear prescription for combating arrogance: recognition of one’s own fallibility, constant mindfulness of Allah’s greatness, and the cultivation of humility through worship, reflection, and service. The Prophet Muhammad’s life serves as a beacon of humility, showing that true greatness lies not in elevating oneself above others but in lowering oneself in service to Allah and humanity.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the notion of original sin in Islam, represented by Shaytan’s arrogance, offers profound insights into the human condition. Arrogance is identified not just as a moral failing, but as the root of all disobedience to Allah, entailing significant ramifications for individuals and communities alike. The challenge posed by arrogance necessitates a vigilant, ongoing effort to cultivate humility and submission to divine will, as pathways to redemption and enlightenment in the Islamic faith.